| 2024 | Gold | Charles Catlett | The Tokens of Thomas Spence |
| Silver | David Schenkman | The Tragic 1904 Baltimore Fire | |
| Bronze | Michael Wehner | The Multiphone Operating Company and Western Multiphone Company Tokens | |
| ________ | ___________ | __________________________ | __________________________________________ |
| 2023 | Gold | Benjamin Gastfriend | Exonumia from the 1912 Norristown Centennial |
| Silver | David Schenkman | Numismatic References of the 19th Century Peace Jubilees | |
| Bronze | Harry Waterson | A Medal for A Message to Garcia - A Medal for A Message to Gomez | |
| ________ | ___________ | __________________________ | __________________________________________ |
| 2022 | Gold | Ernie Nagy | John Brown Execution Medalet: What is Known About its Legends, Mottoes, and Origin |
| Silver | David Schenkman | The Many Faces of "Dr." John H. Pinkard | |
| Bronze | Harry Waterson | A Very Subtle Medal | |
| ________ | ___________ | __________________________ | __________________________________________ |
| 2021 | Gold | Neil Musante | A Washington Token with Some Observations on the Early Career of Charles Cushing Wright |
| Silver | Mike Miller | Award Medals, Medalets, and Exonumia from Louisville's Southern Exposition, 1883-1887 | |
| Bronze | William D. Hyder | Lingering Wisps of Blue Smoke: Santa Cruz, California, Cigar Tokens | |
| ________ | ___________ | __________________________ | __________________________________________ |
| 2020 | Gold | Jud Petrie | Chicago Magic Bar Tokens" |
| Silver | David Schenkman | A Maine To Remember: Numismatic Mementos of The Ill-Fated Battleship | |
| Bronze | William D. Hyder | Big Trouble On Lower State Street: Notorious Saloons In Santa Barbara California | |
| ________ | ___________ | __________________________ | __________________________________________ |
| 2019 | Gold | M/Sgt Ray Bows, U.S. Army (ret) | History of the First Slot Machines in the Far East, the Shanghai Connection, and the Life of E.T. Riley |
| Silver | Jerry F. Schimmel | Chinese-American Tokens: San Francisco's Ross Alley | |
| Bronze | David E. Schenkman | Tokens of the Railroad Y.M.C.A. | |
| ________ | ___________ | __________________________ | __________________________________________ |
| 2018 | Gold | David Schenkman | Tokens Good for a Ride to Nowhere |
| Silver | William Hyder | Merchant Token Ephemera from Wilsey, Kansas | |
| Bronze | Bill Miller | A Token Remembrance of Berlin During the Weimar Republic | |
| ________ | ___________ | __________________________ | __________________________________________ |
| 2017 | Gold | Stephen Petty and Gino Sanfilippo | Heraldic Art Medals |
| Silver | ? | ||
| Bronze | ? | ||
| ________ | ___________ | __________________________ | __________________________________________ |
| 2016 | Gold | Bob Lyall | And the Government Paid For Both of Us to go to Ireland Island |
| Silver | Jerry F. Schimmel | Chinese-American Tokens: More Samples | |
| Bronze | Dennis Tucker | Tarnished Gold: The Unlikely Birth, Troubled Life, and Potential Comeback of the U.S. Mint's American Arts Gold Medallions, Part 2 | |
| Bronze | David E. Schenkman | The Camp Family Dynasty:An American Success Story, Part 2 | |
| ________ | ___________ | __________________________ | __________________________________________ |
| 2015 | Gold | Bruce R. Moshel | The Belfast Collection of Irish Political Tokens |
| Silver | Jerry F. Schimmel | Chinese-American Tokens: A Sampler | |
| Bronze | Benjamin Gastfriend | The Elongated Medals of Emil Fassler | |
| ________ | ___________ | __________________________ | __________________________________________ |
| 2014 | Gold | Eric Schena | State of Confusion: The Buxton & Landstreet Company Store at Kempton, Maryland...or West Virginia? |
| Silver | Donald Dool | Medals Commemorating Jose de San Martin and the Liberation of South America. | |
| Bronze | Leonard Goldberg | Sholl's Cafeteria: Plain Food that was Simply Delicious with an unreported token | |
| ________ | ___________ | __________________________ | __________________________________________ |
| 2013 | Gold | ||
| Silver | |||
| Bronze | |||
| ________ | ___________ | __________________________ | __________________________________________ |
| 2012 | Gold | Fred Reed | Civil War Encased Stamps |
| Silver | David Schenkman | Wishington, DC Wasshington, DC G.A.R. Encampment SouvenirsR. Encampment Souvenirs | |
| Bronze | Q. David Bowers | (Classifying Fanbossed Shell Cards Featuring Coin Designs | |
| ________ | ___________ | __________________________ | __________________________________________ |
| 2011 | Gold | David Schenkman | The Medicinal and Numismatic Legacy of Samuel Taylor Suit |
| Silver | Michael Wehner | The Denman Grammar School Medals of San Francisco | |
| Bronze | Bruce Mosher | James D. McAvoy's Defining Aloment | |
| ________ | ___________ | __________________________ | __________________________________________ |
| 2010 | Gold | William Hyder | San Francisco Exonumia and 1898 Golden Jubilee |
| Silver | Leonard Goldberg | The Iceman Cometh | |
| Bronze | Donald H. Dool | Medals for a liberator | |
| ________ | ___________ | __________________________ | __________________________________________ |
| 2009 | Gold | ||
| Silver | |||
| Bronze | |||
| Honorable Mention | |||
| ________ | ___________ | __________________________ | __________________________________________ |
| 2008 | Gold | ||
| Silver | |||
| Bronze | |||
| Honorable Mention | |||
| ________ | ___________ | __________________________ | __________________________________________ |
| 2007 | Gold | David E. Schenkman | A Look at Steamer Tokens |
| Silver | Robert D. Leonard | Trade Simulator Tokens | |
| Bronze | Nicholas Martin | Royal Air Force Sports Medals | |
| ________ | ___________ | __________________________ | __________________________________________ |
| 2006 | Gold | ||
| Silver | |||
| Bronze | |||
| Honorable Mention | |||
| ________ | ___________ | __________________________ | __________________________________________ |
| 2005 | Gold | Jerry F. Schimmel | A Tale of Two Thalias |
| Silver | Lenny Gold | Fort Dupont, Delaware NCO Club Tokens | |
| Bronze | Phil W. Greenslet | The Medals of Franklin | |
| ________ | ___________ | __________________________ | __________________________________________ |
| 2004 | Gold | ||
| Silver | |||
| Bronze | |||
| Honorable Mention | |||
| ________ | ___________ | __________________________ | __________________________________________ |
| 2003 | Gold | Jerry F. Schimmel | Frisco's Brothel Tokens |
| Silver | Leon L. Robert | Yellow Fever Related Exonumia | |
| Bronze | David E. Schenkman, | ike Pezak: 'Hobo Nickel' Carver | |
| ________ | ___________ | __________________________ | __________________________________________ |
| 2002 | Gold | ||
| Silver | |||
| Bronze | |||
| Honorable Mention | |||
| ________ | ___________ | __________________________ | __________________________________________ |
| 2001 | Gold | ||
| Silver | |||
| Bronze | |||
| Honorable Mention | |||
| ________ | ___________ | __________________________ | __________________________________________ |
| 2000 | Gold | Franc P. Connor | Iowa Card Stock Tokens. |
| Silver | Russell L. Daisley, | The Legacy of the West Greenville PA Civil War Token | |
| Bronze | Leon A. Sarya | An Outstanding Armenian Holocaust Medal" | |
| ________ | ___________ | __________________________ | __________________________________________ |
| 1999 | Gold | Russ Daisle | The Meadville Pennsylvania Civil War Token" |
| Silver | Randy Partin | Order of Owls | |
| Bronze | Frederick J. Schumacher | Martin Luther's Katharina von Bora on Medals and Paper | |
| ________ | ___________ | __________________________ | __________________________________________ |
| 1998 | Gold | David E. Schenkman | Token Mementos of Our National Pastime |
| Silver | Thomas H. Sebring | The Doggersbank Medals" | |
| Bronze | Tim O'Callaghan | Ford Employee Factory Badges" | |
| ________ | ___________ | __________________________ | __________________________________________ |
| 1997 | Gold | Terry Stahurski | Medals, Badges, and tokens of Cleveland's Centennial Celebration |
| Silver | Glyn V. Farber | The Menter Token Story | |
| Bronze | Wm. David Perkins | Tale of Two Tokens: Perkins Hotel and W. Perkins, Jr., Grocer & Provision Dealer | |
| Bronze | Hal V. Dunn | Virgil Earp and the Mystery of His Sawtelle Token | |
| ________ | ___________ | __________________________ | __________________________________________ |
| 1996 | Gold | David E. Schenkman | The Gallery Mint and the Genius of Ron Landis, |
| Silver | Timothy J. O'Callaghan | Ford Motor Company Tokens and Medals of Significant Interest | |
| Bronze | George Fuld | Supplement to "Medallic Memorials to Theodore Roosevelt | |
| Honorable Mention | |||
| ________ | ___________ | __________________________ | __________________________________________ |
| 1995 | Gold | Henry B. Moncure | A History of the Badge of the Seven Confederate Knights, |
| Silver | Thomas H. Sebrin | Tragedy, Heroism and the San Francisco Medals" | |
| Bronze | Henry B. Moncure | Korean Marriage Amulets | |
| ________ | ___________ | __________________________ | __________________________________________ |
| 1994 | Gold | David E. Schenkman | Tokens of the Southern Textile Mill Industry |
| Silver | Wolfgang Bertsch | Tokens from Chile" | |
| Bronze | Jerry F. Schimmel | The Parisian Mansion and Sundry Resorts of Ill Repute" | |
| Honorable Mention | Louis W. Small | World War I Service Medals Issued by Indiana Counties, Cities and Towns | |
| Honorable Mention | Simon Cordova | Revised List of Municipal Trade Dollars of the Islands of Maui and Hawaii" | |
| Honorable Mention | Lawrence C. Korchnak | The Beaver Falls Cutlery Company Counterstamped Half Dollar | |
| ________ | ___________ | __________________________ | __________________________________________ |
| 1993 | Gold | Jerry F. Schimmel | An old ship from the Gold Rush. |
| Silver | Douglas G. Borden | The Alphabet Tokens | |
| Bronze | Gerald Johnson | The Living Legend of IXL | |
| Bronze | Kenneth N. Traub | Magnificent Medallic Masterpieces Of The 1892-3 Columbian Exposition | |
| Honorable Mention | Wayne K. Homren & Lawrence C. Dziubek | The Communion Tokens Of The Second United Presbyterian Church Of Allegheny, Pennsylvania | |
| ________ | ___________ | __________________________ | __________________________________________ |
| 1992 | Gold | Richard Magnuson | Jacob Strahle, Pioneer California Billiard Table Manufacturer. |
| Silver | Douglas G. Borden | Rubber-Tired Trolleys' And Their Tokens | |
| Bronze | Henry B. Moncur | Buried Messages: Barrow Diggers Tokens | |
| Honorable Mention | Dave Moric | The Medieval Coins Of A Modern Kingdom | |
| Honorable Mention | Bruce W. Smith | Chinese Dining Hall Tokens | |
| Honorable Mention | Henry B. Moncure | Sniffing Out A Souvenir: A Perse Is Not A Purse | |
| ________ | ___________ | __________________________ | __________________________________________ |
| 1991 | Gold | William Swoger | An Introduction to Genealogical Numismatic Research. |
| Silver | Henry B. Moncure | The Slot Machine Tokens Used by The United States Military in VietNam | |
| Bronze | Steven A. Middleton | Ferris Wheel Medals of the 1893 World's Columbian Exposition | |
| ________ | ___________ | __________________________ | __________________________________________ |
| 1990 | Gold | David E. Schenkman | Aluminum, and its Early Use in Exonumia. |
| Silver | Gregory G. Brunk | The Characteristics of North American Advertising Countermarks. | |
| Bronze | Gregory G. Brunk | Estimating the Circulation of North American Advertising Countermarks | |
| Honorable Mention | Ben Z. Swanson | Embossed Cachou Boxes | |
| Honorable Mention | J. Toth and E. Zombori | The Numismatic Relics of the Israelitic Religious Communities in I lungary. | |
| Honorable Mention | Henry Moncure | Thai Gambling Tokens | |
| Honorable Mention | William S. Dewey | Medallic Reminder of a Hero's Home | |
| ________ | ___________ | __________________________ | __________________________________________ |
| 1989 | Gold | Andrew Harkness | The American Institute - Catalyst For the American Greatness |
| Silver | O. L. Wallis and William S. Dewey | Admiral George Dewey on Peach Jubilee Medals and Tokens of 1898 - 1899 | |
| Bronze | Philip F. Keller | The Southern Home School, First Honor Gold Medal. | |
| Honorable Mention | Thomas P. Gardner | The Woman on the Back of the Mirror | |
| Honorable Mention | Dave Morice | The Missouri Mule' Gold Piece and Other Little Mysteries. | |
| Honorable Mention | David E. Schenkman | Attributing the Mysterious General Chemical Company Tokens | |
| ________ | ___________ | __________________________ | __________________________________________ |
| 1988 | Gold | David E. Schenkman | |
| Silver | Elizabeth W. Steinle | ||
| Bronze | William S. Dewey | ||
| Honorable Mention | Ronald J. Benice | ||
| Honorable Mention | Robert Doyle | ||
| Honorable Mention | Rodger E. Hershey | ||
| Honorable Mention | Michael L. Kolman | ||
| ________ | ___________ | __________________________ | |
| 1987 | Gold | Thomas P. Gardner | |
| Silver | H. B. Moncure | ||
| Bronze | William E. Fowler | ||
| Honorable Mention | William S. Dewey | ||
| Honorable Mention | John A. Staggs | ||
| ________ | ___________ | __________________________ | |
| 1986 | Gold | James O. Sweeny | |
| Silver | Dan Kilgore | ||
| Bronze | Michael Denning | ||
| Honorable Mention | Bruce K. Cox | ||
| Honorable Mention | Lawrence W. Cobb | ||
| Honorable Mention | Sam Ruggeri | ||
| ________ | ___________ | __________________________ | |
| 1985 | Gold | Charles J. Ricard | |
| Silver | Douglas Borden | ||
| Bronze | (not awarded) | ||
| Honorable Mention | Robert Julian | ||
| Honorable Mention | Cheryl Maisch | ||
| ________ | ___________ | __________________________ | |
| 1984 | Gold | Frederick J. Schumacher | |
| Silver | James O. Sweeny | ||
| Bronze | Sheldon Banoff | ||
| Honorable Mention | Robert J. Thomas | ||
| Honorable Mention | William Fowler | ||
| Honorable Mention | F. D. Hartley and James Krucki | ||
| Honorable Mention | Gerald Johnson | ||
| Honorable Mention | Enoch Nappen | ||
| Honorable Mention | David Gale | ||
| Honorable Mention | Michael J. Denning | ||
| Honorable Mention | Sam Ruggeri | ||
| ________ | ___________ | __________________________ | |
| 1983 | Gold | PAUL CUNNINGHAM | |
| Silver | GERALD JOHNSON | ||
| Bronze | GEORGE CUHAJ | ||
| Honorable Mention | CARL W. A. CARLSON | ||
| Honorable Mention | GARY G. ASCHER | ||
| Honorable Mention | THOMAS GARDNER | ||
| ________ | ___________ | __________________________ | |
| 1982 | Gold | DAVID E. SCHENKMAN | |
| Silver | WILLIAM DEWEY | ||
| Bronze | |||
| Honorable Mention | |||
| Honorable Mention | |||
| ________ | ___________ | __________________________ | |
| 1981 | Gold | DAVID E. SCHENKMAN | |
| Silver | TOM DE LOREY | ||
| Bronze | JOSEPH SCHMIDT | ||
| ________ | ___________ | __________________________ | |
| 1980 | Gold | (not awarded) | |
| Silver | DAVID E. SCHENKMAN | ||
| Bronze | GEORGE CUHAJ | ||
| ________ | ___________ | __________________________ | |
| 1979 | Gold | (not awarded) | |
| Silver | PAUL DILLINGHAM | ||
| Bronze | C. M. LAWRENCE | ||
| Honorable Mention | LANCE GAMMILL & SHILA MASTOFF | ||
| Honorable Mention | TOM CASPER | ||
| ________ | ___________ | __________________________ | |
| 1978 | Gold | GERALD JOHNSON | |
| Silver | R. W. COLBERT & WILLIAM D. HYDER | ||
| Bronze | DAVID E. SCHENKMAN | ||
| Honorable Mention | AUTENCE BASON | ||
| ________ | ___________ | __________________________ | |
| 1977 | Gold | DAVID E. SCHENKMAN | |
| Silver | HAL V. DUNN | ||
| Bronze | DAVID GLADFELTER | ||
| Honorable Mention | GERALD JOHNSON | ||
| Honorable Mention | TOM WALL | ||
| Honorable Mention | MIGUEL MUNOZ | ||
| Honorable Mention | E. BEERSTECHER | ||
| ________ | ___________ | __________________________ | |
| 1976 | Gold | HAL V. DUNN | |
| Silver | DON STEWART | ||
| Bronze | DAVID E. SCHENKMAN | ||
| Honorable Mention | WILLIAM FOWLER | ||
| Honorable Mention | DAVID GLADFELTER | ||
| Honorable Mention | MARK SAWYER | ||
| ________ | ___________ | __________________________ | |
| 1975 | Gold | BILL FOWLER | |
| Silver | HAL V. DUNN | ||
| Bronze | DON STEWART | ||
| Honorable Mention | J. BLAKE GODFREY | ||
| Honorable Mention | HARLEY RHODEHAMEL | ||
| Honorable Mention | WILLIAM O. WEST | ||
| ________ | ___________ | __________________________ | |
| 1974 | Gold | DAVID GLADFELTER | |
| Silver | GERALD JOHNSON | ||
| Bronze | WALTER CALDWELL | ||
| Honorable Mention | JOE DAVICH | ||
| Honorable Mention | WILLIAM D. HYDER & R. W. COLBERT | ||
| ________ | ___________ | __________________________ | |
| 1973 | Gold | ELWIN LESLIE | |
| Silver | ALLAN BERGMAN | ||
| Bronze | DONALD STEWART | ||
| Honorable Mention | GEORGE FRAKES | ||
| Honorable Mention | WILLIAM D. HYDER & R. W. COLBERT | ||
| ________ | ___________ | __________________________ | |
| 1972 | Gold | DAVID GLADFELTER | |
| Silver | ROBERT CRAIGO | ||
| Bronze | ELWIN LESLIE | ||
| Honorable Mention | |||
| Honorable Mention | |||
| Honorable Mention | |||
| ________ | ___________ | __________________________ | |
| 1971 | Gold | DON STEWART | |
| Silver | ELWIN LESLIE | ||
| Bronze | ED QUAGLIANA | Honorable Mention | DWIGHT SAFFORD | Honorable Mention | R. HERBERG | Honorable Mention | SID JOSEPH | Honorable Mention | DAVID GLADFELTER |
| ________ | ___________ | __________________________ | |
| 1970 | Gold | EDGAR HEYL | |
| Silver | JAMES RUHLAND | ||
| Bronze | JAMES SPILMAN | ||
| Honorable Mention | RAY BOWS | Honorable Mention | ORE VACKETTA | Honorable Mention | GORDON DODRILL |
| ________ | ___________ | __________________________ | |
| 1969 | Gold | CLYDE DREWING | |
| Silver | GUENTER KEINAST | ||
| Bronze | ROBERT LINDESMITH | ||
| Honorable Mention | ARLIE SLABAUGH | ||
| Honorable Mention | EDGAR HEYL | ||
| Honorable Mention | RAY BYRNE | ||
| ________ | ___________ | __________________________ | |
| 1968 | Gold | MELVIN FULD | |
| Silver | F. HOLSTINE | ||
| Bronze | TERRY TRANTOW | ||
| Bronze | ARLIE SLABAUGH | ||
| ________ | ___________ | __________________________ | |
| 1967 | Gold | DON DECKER | |
| Silver | ROBERT LINDESMITH | ||
| Bronze | ELWIN LESLIE | ||
| ________ | ___________ | __________________________ | |
| 1966 | Gold | MELVIN FULD | |
| Silver | ARLIE SLABAUGH | ||
| Bronze | JAY GUREN, R. UGAN & JIM CURTO | ||
| ________ | ___________ | __________________________ | |
| 1965 | Gold | VIRGINIA CULVER | |
| Silver | NATHAN EGLIT | ||
| Bronze | ED ROCHETTE | ||
| ________ | ___________ | __________________________ | |
| 1964 | Gold | ROBERT LINDESMITH | |
| Silver | ARLIE SLABAUGH | ||
| Bronze | VIRGINIA CULVER | ||
| ________ | ___________ | __________________________ | |
| 1963 | Gold | (not awarded) | |
| Silver | GEORGE FULD | ||
| Bronze | HOWARD LINECAR | ||
| ________ | ___________ | __________________________ | |
| 1961-1962 | Gold | (not awarded) | |
| Silver | RALPH MITCHELL | ||
| Silver | RUSSELL RULAU | ||
| Bronze | MORRIS ABBOT | ||
| ________ | ___________ | __________________________ |